Skip to content


Shakespeare & Claims: Looking Inward

Looking In From The Outside

Ariana Huffington recently wrote about taking responsibility for ones own action in her article On Dominique Strauss-Kahn, Shakespeare, and the Enemy in the Mirror.  As she reflected on some of the recent news of the week and reminded us that

in the game of life, as Cassius said in Julius Caesar, “The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars — but in ourselves…” This was a frequent theme of Shakespeare’s, who put it another way in All’s Well That Ends Well, when Helena says: “Our remedies oft in ourselves do lie, which we ascribe to Heaven.”

So what the heck doe this have to do with claims? More than might appear at first glance.

Insurance companies and claims departments are quick to blame all sorts of issues when problems arise. The loss was unexpected, we didn’t know the information was available, or my favorite, it was the other guy’s fault. As Ms. Huffington went on to write

In the end, if we spent even a small percentage of the time we devote to obsessing about those we consider our rivals, competitors, and enemies on examining where our own fault lines are, it’s hard to believe we wouldn’t be more successful

For companies to be successful they must look inward and then act on what they learn.

Don’t Let History Repeat Itself

Recently I was part of a claim review that found significant issues in not only how claims were being managed, but in how policies were being issued. I provided my report and commentary about what was found. Regardless, the client chose to move forward to renew the account.  It reminded me again of the time when we in claims had recommended the company get out of a particular class of business only to be told “it’s OK we doubled the premium.” Then reality sank in two years later when the loss ratios went over 220%.

Now I am not against writing business. I agree with the principal I learned from the CEO of one of my former companies that it’s not about not writing business it’s about writing the right business at the right prices and terms. Regardless, reviews done in both those cases provided valuable information that could help to improve the operation.

Claims auditing is a way to look inward and learn the faults within our ourselves.  A good claims review can identify weaknesses and provide a road map to improve an operation.  Regular reviews can help prevent surprise and insure the department continues to improve. Of course, the information needs to be used to improve decision making and not ignored.  As has been said “those who ignore history are bound (or doomed) to repeat it.”

Learn From What You Already Know And Review Your Claims Regularly

Print This Post Print This Post

Posted in Claims Auditing, Commentary.

Tagged with , , , .


2 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Dan Williams says

    I think when you add in the factor that many independant agents “sugar coat” business when it’s submitted as new, they’ve already set the stage for claims to have issues. Then underwriting is skocked when they discover what type of risk they actually bought into.

  2. dan @ maryland health insurance says

    so many people do not take responsibility for their actions that is dispacable to our race as humans. Don’t these people have parents that raised them correctly.

    If you don’t take responsibilty for yourself who are you going to take responsibilty for. it it quite ridiculous.

    I was raised to know that whatever action i took i would be responsible for the outcome



Some HTML is OK

or, reply to this post via trackback.

Captcha Captcha Reload